What Do Professors Look for in an Essay? Key Criteria Explained

Academic Writing

11 min read

What Do Professors Look for in an Essay? Key Criteria Explained

Professors assess essays for originality, authenticity, critical thinking, and structure. Learn exactly what professors look for in an essay and how to meet their academic expectations.

What Do Professors Look For In Your Essay

Written by

Viktoriia Y.

Published on

Sep 10, 2025

Table of contents

What Do College Professors Look for in Writing? Key Requirements Explained
To Sum Up

Table of contents

What Do College Professors Look for in Writing? Key Requirements Explained
To Sum Up

Stay Informed

Get the inside scoop with our latest news!

Getting what professors expect from you is no easy task. Many students feel overwhelmed by all the requirements for academic papers. But understanding what professors want to see in essay assignments can eliminate that confusion. Research shows that students perform better when they comprehend the criteria behind academic tasks (Irvin, 2010; Bean, 2011).

This guide breaks down what faculty look for in detail. Specifically for clarity, argumentation, structure, originality, and how to align your writing accordingly. Our goal? To help you write text acceptable for college-level writing and to meet expectations and earn top marks.

What Do College Professors Look for in Writing? Key Requirements Explained

If you are struggling to meet your professor’s expectations in academic writing, you are not alone. The knowledge of what college professors look for in writing can change everything. Professors typically evaluate essays based on content quality, logical structure, originality, grammar, clarity, and adherence to assignment guidelines. So, to graduate from school, you will need to get and learn these skills: how to work with college writing assignments.

What Professors Expect from College Writing

Understand the Topic

Most students struggle to understand the writing assignment task. What do you need to do? Follow the teacher's instructions by heart, do not be afraid to ask and re-ask questions. Discuss with your teacher the intent of the writing so you can define the thesis statement, the relevance of the arguments, and the appropriate tone.

In college writing, knowing what professors expect from college essay submissions means grasping the prompt, addressing it directly, and tailoring the content to an academic readership. Without this foundation, even well-written work may fail to meet the assignment’s goals or earn top marks.

Completes Essay Assignments Independently

The main difference between high school and college-level education is that at the uni, professors expect students to function and work completely independently. To demonstrate their own understanding and critical thinking in academic work, which is why essays should be written independently.

Submitting assignments completed by third parties undermines the learning process and makes it difficult for instructors to assess actual progress. But it doesn't mean the only things you can use are pens and paper. You are encouraged to use AI-powered technologies to brainstorm more ideas, to make sure you are not making any mistakes, and to conduct proper research. For example, AI writing assistant StudyPro can support students in the early stages. By helping them brainstorm ideas, outline structure, or refine arguments, without replacing their own thinking or voice in the final submission.

Write an Introduction That Stands Out

To get the readers' interest, you need to start with a captivating introduction, so the professors expect that. The introduction not only sets the tone but also demonstrates clarity of thought and purpose. A well-structured opening should hook the reader through an interesting quote, a thought-provoking question, or a relevant statistic. It should then provide enough background to establish context and lead naturally into a clearly defined thesis statement. For inspiration, many rely on solid introduction paragraph examples to guide their structure and tone.

Write Evidence-Based Arguments

The focus of any complete and good academic paper or work is the evidence it is based on. Professors usually demand well-supported arguments grounded in facts, statistics, or academic references, which is exactly what students should consider when thinking about what do professors look for in essays. Students should not only present their viewpoint but also explore multiple perspectives to demonstrate depth of understanding. Additionally, professors want students to reflect on what they’ve learned in class. This combination of insight and structure reveals how well a student has understood the subject.

Clarity in Essay Structure

Great essays must follow effective writing strategies to keep a logical flow and clear expression. This includes using topic sentences to introduce each paragraph, cohesive transitions between ideas, and proper language. Professors value writing that is easy to follow and clearly communicates the writer’s intent. Disorganized essays with vague statements often signal weak understanding.

Show Originality of Own Ideas

What a professor wants in essay assignments goes beyond correct grammar or structure. Otherwise, it would be too easy. Student must obtain strong research skills to present the originality of their ideas. Professors highly estimate independent analysis, personal insight, and arguments that show a genuine understanding of the topic. Professors reward essays that are thoughtfully written, well-structured.

Implementing the Research Methodology

Now, let's discuss one of the most important processes in creating an academic paper. Most professors expect students to demonstrate that a considerable amount of preparation has gone into their essays. That includes thorough research, thoughtful planning, critical evaluation of sources, and organization of the content.

Use Correct Citations & Formatting

Professors expect college essays to be formatted and cite their work with precision and consistency. Proper formatting isn’t just about aesthetics, but it reflects academic discipline and respect for scholarly work. Student should clarify the correct citation style with their academic institution. Here are examples of different formatting.

Proper Grammar

Professors expect in essay to find proper grammar, style, accurate punctuation, and spelling in your work. Strong academic writing also avoids slang, filler words, or informal phrasing. Every sentence should contribute to the argument, using language that reflects critical thought. To succeed, students must check for grammar mistakes before submission.

Students should avoid these mistakes:

Avoid using filler words: ‘like’, ‘really’.

Example: Nowadays, people are like really into technology.

Try: Today, society increasingly relies on advanced technologies.

Avoid slang.

Example: There’s a bunch of stuff we can learn from history.

Try: Historical analysis provides critical insights into modern policymaking.

Avoid vague personal opinions.

Example: I think pollution is bad and we should fix it.

Try: Environmental pollution poses measurable threats to public health, necessitating urgent policy interventions.

Strong Conclusion

A strong conclusion is not just a summary; it’s your final chance to leave an impression. Professors expect students to demonstrate their ability to synthesize key points and summarize all the data into an impactful conclusion. Students must close all of their mentioned arguments. In short, professors expect an essay to end with a well-structured final paragraph that clearly reflects the argument presented, reinforces the thesis, and leaves no loose ends, showing maturity in thought and clarity in academic communication.

Clear and Focused Thesis

Professors expect essays to begin with a strong, well-defined thesis that serves as the foundation for the entire paper. This thesis should clearly state the main argument and be supported with relevant evidence throughout the essay. In the conclusion, students should always restate a thesis, rephrasing it slightly to reinforce their main point and show how their argument has been developed through logical progression.

To Sum Up

To make sure an essay meets professors’ expectations, students must clearly understand the assignment, write with purpose, and support a strong thesis with analysis. Avoid vague generalizations and instead present original thinking, research skills, and logical structure. Use proper citations, keep academic tone and grammar, and don’t be afraid to use AI-powered tools like StudyPro to work on your arguments and formatting. Clarity, structure, and authenticity are key to standing out.

Simplify academic writing with StudyPro

Your everything platform that supports real assignments. Stay focused, organized, and inspired with our help.

Get started now

Frequently asked questions

Professors typically grade essays based on several key requirements: understanding of the topic, originality, logical structure, clarity, proper formatting, source integration, and grammar. They look for a strong thesis, supported arguments, and critical thinking throughout the essay. Academic tone and adherence to citation style (APA, MLA, etc.) also affect scores. To stand out, write clearly, show what you’ve learned, don’t just summarize, analyze.

To earn an A+ on your essay, focus on clarity, originality, and structure. Begin with an interesting thesis, support every argument with strong evidence, and follow proper formatting (APA, MLA, etc.). Use varied sentence structure, precise grammar, and an academic tone. Show your critical thinking abilities, not just summarizing. Avoid filler words and clichés. Professors also expect independent work, thorough research, and correct citations. Use tools like StudyPro to brainstorm, outline, and polish your writing to meet academic expectations.

College professors value originality, critical thinking, and clarity in student writing. They expect well-structured essays with a strong thesis, logical flow, and evidence-based arguments. Proper grammar, formatting, and citation styles (APA, MLA, etc.) matter, as do authentic voice and analytical depth.

Sources:

Sampson, E. (2007). Essay writing handbook. Retrieved from https://www.academia.edu/4046467/EssayWritingHandbook
Irvin, L. L. (n.d.). What is academic writing? In C. Lowe & P. Zemliansky (Eds.), Writing Spaces: Readings on Writing, Volume 1 (pp. 3–17). Parlor Press. https://wac.colostate.edu/books/writingspaces1/irvin–what-is-academic-writing.pdf
Purdue. (2021b, February 12). College Writing & Professor Expectations. Purdue University Global Academic Success Center. https://purdueglobalwriting.center/2021/02/12/college-writing-professor-expectations/